
By Blaise Patrick Tracy
Across my work with clients in a range of industries, I’ve noticed the same pattern: the organizations that struggle with community engagement – both internally and externally – usually aren’t struggling because they aren’t communicating enough. They’re struggling because they’re communicating in one direction.
There’s a real difference between talking to a community and talking at one.
Let’s think about the noise that’s out there hitting us from all sides on every platform – the internet, the intranet, social media, opinion pieces, media narratives, advertisements online, on radio, on television, on public transportation, and on the side of the road.
Plus, newsletters, pop-ups, emails, phone calls, texts, messaging apps, and let’s also count the dozens of community networking events every month that we may need to attend for the good of the order.
All talking at us. All assuming they know what’s best for us, many without even having met us!
Here are a few things that hit our audience hard. And if we keep it up, we may not recover. And, yes, I’ll share ideas on how to shift from it.
Every Message Is an Announcement
If the only time our organization shows up in our community’s inbox, feed, or mailbox is to tell them something — a new policy, new hours, a new initiative — that’s one-directional communication. And it’s exhaustingly boring, especially if we also send out follow-up reminders, regurgitating the same old messages from before.
Sharing updates is fine, but if that’s a high majority of our messaging, our audience starts to tune it out. Communication that only flows outward eventually stops landing at all.
Good: Find the hook, the request, or the objective – and lead with it.
Better: Also provide a personal angle, imagery, and the ‘why it matters to our audience’; and when appropriate, make it fun.
We’re Not Listening First
The clients I’ve worked with who do this well share one habit: they ask before they announce. That can be as simple as a short survey before a policy change, a listening session before a new program launches, a quick team discussion, or genuinely reading the comments on a community post instead of only replying to the positive ones. When people feel asked, they engage differently
Good: Remind our audience that we asked them, thank them for their input, and share the relevant results.
Better: Provide details, share next steps, and keep it positive.
It’s Tough to Talk to Us
A lot of organizations build one-way channels without realizing it. This often includes a newsletter with no reply or feedback option, a website ‘contact us’ form that may take days or weeks to respond (or no response at all), an announcement with no direction on who can help answer questions – and my favorite, a message from an entity, group, or ‘team’, not an individual. All of these are distant and they dilute accountability.
If our community has no easy way to respond to us, we’ve built a megaphone, not a conversation.
Good: Develop something for two-way conversation. It can be as simple as a monitored inbox (with rapid responses), an open comment section, or a real person with an email and a phone number.
Better: Also provide brief status updates to the entire organization in quarterly updates or town halls. This will continue to show we are always listening.
Feedback Doesn’t Change Anything
This one is brutal. The fastest way to lose community trust is to ask for input and then visibly ignore it. The organizations that build real community relationships close the loop — they come back and say, “Here’s what we heard, and here’s what we changed because of it.”
Even when we can’t act on every piece of feedback, acknowledging it publicly shows our community their voice reaches a real person and has been considered.
Good: On the items we cannot get to now, or may have said ‘no’ to, let’s explain our reasoning.
Better: Don’t wait a year to ask in an ‘annual survey’; it’s ineffective in addressing timely needs and lumps all suggestions into a monster pile of to-do’s that can be overwhelming for a team to address properly.
We are Not Where Our Audience Is
Talking at a community often looks like using the channel that’s easiest for the organization, not the one that’s easiest for the audience. Imagine our community who primarily engages on social media and instead of prioritizing where they are, we are using snail mail.
Communication has many options and our audience chooses what works best for them. If we have an older audience and we’ve decided an app is the way to inform, we may be optimizing for our own convenience instead of their attention.
Good: Go to where the audience is.
Better: Train them in new tools, keep the tools that work best, and simplify the information flow.
Bottom Line
Community engagement is not a broadcast function — it’s a relationship. The brands that get it right aren’t necessarily the ones with the biggest budgets or the flashiest campaigns; they are the ones willing to listen first, make it easy to respond, and show their community that input leads somewhere.
If we show up for our audience, most likely, our audience will show up for us.
